[pjw] NEWS: Trump threatens Korea, Iran, others in UN speech (Politico 9/19)
Peace and Justice Works
pjw at pjw.info
Tue Sep 19 15:39:27 EDT 2017
IAG supporters
The timing of our protest this Friday (5 PM at SW Yamhill and Broadway)
could not be more important. President Trump has used the world's
deliberative body that was nominally set up to resolve global conflicts
after WW II to threaten war on North Korea, Iran, and other countries. Our
description of Friday's rally, though titled "Stop the US War on Syria,"
also notes that "PJW also opposes future wars, including, in the context
of the 64th anniversary of the armistice in Korea on July 27, ongoing US
tensions with North Korea."
He threatened to "totally destroy" North Korea.
To me one of the biggest hypocrisies (among the many) is Trump's
description of Iran:
"The Iranian government masks a corrupt dictatorship behind the false
guise of a democracy," Trump said. He accused the Islamist government
in Tehran of turning a wealthy nation with a rich history into "an
economically depleted rogue state whose chief exports are violence,
bloodshed and chaos."
Hmm, who does that sound like... maybe the USA???
Politico's story (below) does include this useful insight:
[Trump] may rail against human rights abuses in Iran, for instance,
but he says nothing about similar abuses in U.S.-allied countries
such as Egypt or Saudi Arabia -- a position past presidents have
also taken.
They also note he didn't talk about the US pulling out of the Paris
climate accord.
http://www.politico.com/story/2017/09/19/trump-warns-against-authoritarian-regimes-in-un-speech-242876
Trump warns that major portions of the world "are going to hell"
The president also threatens to 'totally destroy' North Korea during
his first United Nations address.
By NAHAL TOOSI and NOLAN D. MCCASKILL
09/19/2017 10:18 AM EDT
Updated 09/19/2017 02:13 PM EDT
2017-09-19T02:13-0400
UNITED NATIONS -- President Donald Trump threatened Tuesday to "totally
destroy" North Korea and its "Rocket Man" leader, warned the
"murderous" Iranian government that it cannot endure, and declared that
much of the world is "going to hell."
In his first speech to the U.N. General Assembly, Trump also urged
nations to band together to fight "evil" -- even as he extolled the
virtue of respecting national sovereignty and insisted that America
isn't looking to impose its "way of life" on others.
The at-times contradictory remarks were filled with soaring rhetoric
that touched on everything from "God" to "chaos," and the dark tones
were reminiscent of Trump's inaugural address, in which he promised to
bring an end to "American carnage." The singling out of a handful of
"rogue" nations also seemed to borrow from former President George W.
Bush's "Axis of Evil" speech.
"The scourge of our planet today is small regimes that violate every
principle [on which] the United Nations is based," Trump said. "They
respect neither their own citizens nor the sovereign rights of their
countries. If the righteous many do not confront the wicked few, then
evil will triumph."
The speech seemed crafted to please Trump's nationalist-leaning
domestic base without alienating global leaders. Stephen Miller, a
Trump aide with nationalist and anti-immigration views, is reported to
have helped draft it, and Trump, known for talking off the cuff, seemed
to stay largely on script.
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, a major supporter of Trump
who is eager to see him crack down on Iran, was among the world leaders
openly thrilled with the address. Israel is often the target of
criticism by U.N. entities and harbors deep suspicion toward the world
body.
"In over 30 years in my experience with the U.N., I never heard a
bolder or more courageous speech," Netanyahu said, according to his
Twitter feed.
Other foreign diplomats were relieved by Trump's 40-minute speech,
although many approached the address with low expectations. Some were
reassured that, even though he urged it to reform itself, Trump at
least did not completely turn his back on the United Nations.
"It was as Trumpian as expected, and we are getting used to it," one
European diplomat said.
Trump's main target of criticism was North Korea, whose nuclear
ambitions have deeply alarmed the White House.
The U.S. president went beyond his past warning that North Korea would
face "fire and fury," and belittled North Korean leader Kim Jong Un by
again calling him "Rocket Man," but this time in a formal setting.
Trump also mentioned Otto Warmbier, a young American held for months by
the regime in Pyongyang who was handed back to the U.S. in a coma and
died shortly thereafter.
"No one has shown more contempt for other nations and for the
well-being of their own people than the depraved regime in North
Korea," Trump said. "No nation on Earth has an interest in seeing this
band of criminals arm itself with nuclear weapons and missiles. The
United States has great strength and patience, but if it is forced to
defend itself or its allies, we will have no choice but to totally
destroy North Korea.
"Rocket Man," Trump said, "is on a suicide mission for himself and for
his regime."
Trump insisted that the United States is "ready, willing and able" to
attack North Korea, but added that "hopefully this will not be
necessary." Instead, Trump said, the United Nations should do more in a
concerted way to force North Korea off the nuclear path.
"That's what the United Nations is all about. That's what the United
Nations is for," he said.
Trump aides later tried to calm the hype over his threats against North
Korea. White House Press Secretary Sarah Huckabee Sanders noted that
former President Barack Obama had used similar language in 2016: "We
could, obviously, destroy North Korea with our arsenals."
Trump also singled out Iran as another common enemy of "righteous"
nations, slamming its military activity throughout the Middle East, its
human rights abuses and its ballistic missile tests.
"The Iranian government masks a corrupt dictatorship behind the false
guise of a democracy," Trump said. He accused the Islamist government
in Tehran of turning a wealthy nation with a rich history into "an
economically depleted rogue state whose chief exports are violence,
bloodshed and chaos." But he also spoke of solidarity with the Iranian
people, whom he cast as "the longest suffering victims" of their
leaders.
Trump further used the occasion to send a strong public signal that he
may abandon the nuclear deal with Iran negotiated by the Obama
administration and several other countries. The agreement, which lifted
many sanctions on Iran in exchange for curbs on its nuclear program, is
"one of the worst and most one-sided transactions" in the history of
America, Trump said, calling it "an embarrassment to the United
States."
"I don't think you've heard the last of it. Believe me," he added.
Trump also went after Venezuela in unusually lengthy and harsh terms,
alleging that its increasingly autocratic government has taken "a
once-thriving nation to the brink of total collapse." He noted that the
U.S. has imposed sanctions on Venezuela, where people are struggling to
obtain basic food and goods amid an economic freefall, and called on
fellow U.N. members to add even more pressure.
"We are prepared to take further action if the government of Venezuela
persists on its path to impose authoritarian rule on the Venezuelan
people," Trump said, without offering specifics. "The situation is
completely unacceptable, and we cannot stand by and watch."
"The problem in Venezuela is not that socialism has been poorly
implemented," Trump added, "but that socialism has been faithfully
implemented."
As he touched on a range of other issues, from the ongoing fight
against "radical Islamic terrorism" to the massive migration crisis
spurred by civil wars and other conflict, Trump painted an overall
pessimistic view of the world.
"Major portions of the world are in conflict and some, in fact, are
going to hell," the U.S. president said.
But the solutions Trump offered at times seemed to contradict each
other, or at least seem difficult to implement given the complexities
of foreign relations.
For instance, Trump nodded to the importance of multilateralism, saying
at one point that "the powerful people in this room, under the guidance
and auspices of the United Nations, can solve many of these vicious and
complex problems."
But much of his speech was focused on respecting national sovereignty
and the right of a country to protect its interests. In fact, he said,
the United Nations itself was initially "based on the vision that
diverse nations could cooperate to protect their sovereignty, preserve
their security, and promote their prosperity."
"The true question for the United Nations today, for people all over
the world who hope for better lives for themselves and their children,
is a basic one -- are we still patriots?" Trump said. "Do we love our
nations enough to protect their sovereignty and to take ownership of
their futures? Do we revere them enough to defend their interests,
preserve their cultures, and ensure a peaceful world for their
citizens?"
The emphasis on patriotism, culture and sovereignty echoed in part
Trump's speech in Poland earlier this year, when he said, "The
fundamental question of our time is whether the West has the will to
survive." Conservatives praised that speech as a stirring defense of
liberal democracy against threats like Islamist extremism, but critics
said it was religiously and racially divisive.
Analysts noted that Trump's actions in office so far seem to both
support and undercut the various points he made Tuesday. He may rail
against human rights abuses in Iran, for instance, but he says nothing
about similar abuses in U.S.-allied countries such as Egypt or Saudi
Arabia -- a position past presidents have also taken.
And when it comes to facing shared, even existential challenges, most
of the rest of the world has banded together to tackle the dangers of
climate change. But Trump has pulled out of the Paris climate deal and
did not mention the issue during his speech Tuesday.
The speech was "full of obvious contradictions on the idea of
sovereignty as a core principle of American engagement in the world,"
said Kelly Magsamen, a former U.S. Defense Department official in the
Obama administration. "On the one hand, it was 'every country for
itself,' except that we want and need countries to address threats like
North Korea collectively."
Stewart Patrick, an U.N. expert with the Council on Foreign Relations,
added that there is broad international support for sticking to the
Iran nuclear deal, but in the interests of "national sovereignty,"
Trump seems likely to walk away -- undercutting goodwill from other
countries.
Still, Patrick added, Trump has a point when he stresses that being
part of the United Nations does not mean giving up a country's
sovereignty. "The reception will be largely good internationally -- he's
not willing to blow up the United Nations," Patrick said.
Trump's decision not to mention Russia by name in the speech also
intrigued diplomats and others parsing his words.
Trump has long said he wants the U.S. to have a better relationship
with Russia, although he has dismissed U.S. intelligence assessments
that Russian interference helped him win the presidency. On Tuesday, he
actually took a veiled shot at Moscow when he spoke of threats to the
sovereignty of Ukraine.
Trump also was kept his references to China oblique: He briefly alluded
to threats to sovereignty in the South China Sea, blasted countries
that trade with North Korea, and said the U.S. would no longer put up
with trade practices that treat Americans unfairly.
More information about the pjw-list
mailing list